03Perspectives

Write the decision down before you make it

A memo of a page or two, written before the choice is made, improves the decision and leaves a record of why it was made.

Most businesses keep careful records of what they decided. The board minutes record the resolution. The contract records the terms. What is rarely written down is why the decision was made: what the people deciding believed, what they expected to happen, and what worried them.

A decision memo fills that gap. It is a short document, written before the choice is made, that sets out the decision, the options, the reasoning and the expectations. It is not a board paper in the usual sense, and it is not a business case written to win approval. It records the reasoning behind the choice while that reasoning can still change the choice.

Why write it before, not after

A record written afterwards is a justification. Memory edits itself in favour of the outcome, and it is hard to write honestly about a decision once you know how it turned out. A memo written before the choice records what you knew and believed at the time, which is the only fair basis for judging the decision later.

Writing first also changes the decision. An argument that sounds convincing in a meeting often looks thin on paper. Gaps in the reasoning become visible. Assumptions that everyone was nodding along to have to be stated, and once they are stated, some of them look less safe. Writing is a way of testing.

What goes in it

A useful memo fits on one or two pages. It covers eight things.

  1. The decision. One question, with the date by which it must be answered.
  2. The options. Each option you considered, including doing nothing, in a sentence or two.
  3. The choice. The option you are choosing.
  4. The reasons. Why this option and not the others. Three or four reasons are enough. If there are ten, the important ones are buried.
  5. The assumptions. What has to be true for the choice to work. Be specific. “Our two largest customers renew on similar terms” is useful. “Customers remain loyal” is not.
  6. The risks you are accepting. What could go wrong, and what you would do if it did.
  7. What you expect to see. The signs, within a stated time, that the decision is working, and the signs that it is not.
  8. What would make you change course. The point at which you would stop or reverse.

The last two items do the most work. They turn a decision into something you can check.

Who writes it and who reads it

The person accountable for the decision should write the memo, or someone close enough to the reasoning to write it honestly. Everyone who will vote on the decision should read it before the meeting where they vote.

If someone reads the memo and disagrees, that is useful. The disagreement can be dealt with before the decision, instead of coming out six months later as “I always had my doubts”.

Use plain words

Write the memo as you would explain the decision to an intelligent person from outside the business. Avoid the language of board papers. A promised saving should name the amount and where it comes from. A claim that two businesses belong together should say what each gains from the other. If a sentence cannot be made plain, the thinking behind it is probably not finished.

Length matters too. A memo of two pages gets read properly. A memo of twenty gets skimmed, and the reasoning is lost. Supporting analysis can sit in an appendix. The memo itself should take ten minutes to read.

Come back to it

The memo earns its keep a second time when you return to it. Set a date, perhaps six or twelve months ahead, to read it again. Compare what you expected with what happened. Did the assumptions hold? Did the risks you named appear, or different ones? Did you see the signs you said you would watch for?

This review is not about blame. A good decision can have a bad outcome, and a poor decision can be rescued by luck. The memo lets you tell the two apart. Over time, a business that reviews its decision memos learns where its judgement is reliable and where it tends to be optimistic. That knowledge is hard to come by any other way.

A small habit

Writing a decision memo takes an afternoon. For a decision that will shape the business for years, that is not much. Start with the next significant decision you face, and write the page before the meeting. You may find the decision changes as you write. If it does not, you will at least know why you made it, and so will whoever has to live with it after you.