03Perspectives

Most bad decisions are framed badly

A decision often goes wrong before anyone looks at the options. The question was too narrow, asked too early, or not the real one.

When a decision turns out badly, the review afterwards usually looks at the choice. Was the forecast wrong? Did we pick the wrong partner, the wrong site, the wrong moment? They are fair questions, and they often miss the point. Many poor decisions were settled before anyone weighed an option. They were settled when someone wrote down the question.

The framing is the sentence that says what is being decided. “Should we open a second site in Manchester?” is a framing. So is “How do we double our capacity in the north within three years?” Both might end with the same building. They lead to different conversations. The first invites a yes or a no. The second invites options, and Manchester is one of them.

Three faults account for most bad framing.

The question is too narrow

A yes-or-no question about a single option is the commonest fault. It feels decisive. It is also the easiest way to stop a board thinking. Once the question is “should we buy this company?”, the discussion turns to whether this company is good enough, not to whether buying any company is the right way to get what you want. The alternatives never get a fair hearing: building the capability yourself, working with another business, or leaving things as they are. Nobody asked about them.

A useful test is to ask what the decision is for. If the answer is “to get into the healthcare market”, the question should be about getting into the healthcare market. Buying this company is one answer to it.

The question arrives too early

Some decisions are framed before the problem is understood. A business losing margin decides to cut costs, and the question becomes “where do we cut?” Perhaps the margin is going because prices have not moved in four years, or because one large customer has renegotiated without much fuss. Cutting costs is a reasonable answer to some of those problems and the wrong answer to others. The framing chose the answer before anyone had worked out the cause.

The cure is to spend longer on the problem than feels comfortable. Write down what has changed, what you know, and what you are guessing. If the guesses outnumber the facts, the decision is not ready to frame.

The question is not the real one

Owners and boards sometimes debate one question while deciding another. A discussion about hiring a managing director can really be about whether the owner is ready to let go. A discussion about a new market can really be about whether the existing business has a future. When the stated question and the real one differ, the debate goes round in circles, because the arguments that matter are never said out loud.

This is the hardest fault to fix, because fixing it takes candour. It helps to ask each person involved what would need to be true for them to be content with the outcome. Their answers often show what the real question is.

What a good framing contains

A well-framed decision fits on a page. It says:

  • what is being decided, as a question that allows more than one answer;
  • why the decision is needed now, and the date by which it must be made;
  • which options are in scope, and which have been ruled out and why;
  • what a good outcome looks like, in terms the people deciding would recognise;
  • what evidence would change the answer.

The last item is the most useful and the most often missed. If nobody can say what would change their mind, the decision has already been made, and the analysis that follows is decoration.

Writing the page takes a few hours. Agreeing it takes longer, because it brings out the disagreements that would otherwise appear months later, in the middle of the work. That time is well spent. A disagreement about the question costs very little to settle before the analysis starts, and a great deal to settle afterwards.

Rewriting the question is not a retreat

Leaders sometimes resist rewriting a question because it feels like going backwards. The board asked whether to buy the company, and now someone wants to discuss the whole plan for growth. It can look like delay, or like a way of avoiding the decision. It is neither. If a better question exists, the original one was always going to produce a weaker answer. The time to find that out is at the start, while changing course costs a conversation rather than a set of abandoned legal fees.

One practical habit helps. Before any analysis begins, read the framing aloud to the people who will make the decision, and ask whether it is the question they want answered. If anyone hesitates, stop and find out why. The hesitation is usually the most useful thing said that day.

The test of a good framing

A decision is well framed when the people making it agree on what they are choosing between, why it matters now, and what would change their minds. Get that right and the choice becomes easier to make. It will not become easy, because decisions of this size rarely are. But you will be making the right decision, and not a neighbouring one that happened to be easier to write down.