03Perspectives

Deciding without waiting for certainty

Waiting for certainty is itself a decision, and often a costly one. Deciding well means knowing what you need to find out and what you can live without.

Every significant business decision is made with incomplete information. The market might turn. The buyer might walk away. The new managing director might not work out. Nobody making a decision of any size has certainty, and people who wait for it tend to find that events have made the decision for them.

Information still matters, and instinct is no substitute for analysis. The question to ask is not “do we know enough to be certain?” but “do we know enough to choose?” The two questions have different answers.

Waiting is a choice

Putting off a decision feels safe. It keeps every option open and avoids the risk of being wrong. Delay has costs too, and they are easy to miss because nobody writes them down. The opportunity may pass. A competitor may move first. The people waiting for the decision lose heart, or leave. A problem left alone usually grows.

When a decision is postponed, name what is being chosen. Postponing is the option of “not yet”, and it should be weighed like any other option: what it costs, what it gains, and how long it can last before it turns into a decision not to act at all.

Separate what you can learn from what you cannot

Uncertainty comes in two kinds. Some of it can be reduced with more work: a survey of customers, a closer look at a target’s contracts, a conversation with a possible buyer. Some of it cannot be reduced at any reasonable cost, such as the future path of interest rates, or how a market will respond to something nobody has tried.

The first kind is worth reducing, up to a point. Ask what the extra information would cost in money and time, and whether any likely result could change the answer. If no plausible result would change the decision, the information is not worth waiting for, however interesting it might be.

The second kind has to be lived with. The useful response is not more analysis. It is a choice that holds up across the range of things that might happen.

Prefer choices that survive being wrong

When the future is unclear, the option to choose is not always the one with the largest prize if things go well. Often it is the one that does acceptably across most of the outcomes you can imagine, and does not fail badly in any of them.

Some practical ways to build that in:

  • Prefer decisions that can be reversed or taken in stages. A trial in one region can come before a national launch. A joint venture can come before a merger.
  • Keep the cost of being wrong survivable. Ask what the worst plausible outcome would do to the business, and whether you could recover from it.
  • Agree in advance what you will watch for, and what you will do if you see it.

Set the threshold before you look

A common pattern in delayed decisions is the moving threshold. The board asks for more evidence. The evidence arrives and broadly supports going ahead, but now the board wants a little more. Each request is reasonable on its own. Together, they mean the decision is never taken.

The remedy is to agree, before gathering more information, what you would need to see to go ahead and what would make you stop. Write it down. When the information arrives, compare it with what you agreed. If it meets the threshold, decide. If it does not, decide that too.

Say how sure you are

Uncertainty is easier to handle when people say how confident they are. A forecast given as a single number invites false precision. A range, with a plain statement of what would push the outcome towards either end, is more useful and more honest.

The same goes for judgement. “I think this will work” is less helpful than “I think this is more likely to work than not, and this is what would change my mind.” Boards make better decisions when the people informing them say what they do not know.

Accept that you might be wrong

A decision made well can still turn out badly. That is the nature of uncertainty, and it is no reason to stop deciding. What matters is that the decision was reasonable given what was known, that the risks were understood and accepted, and that there was a plan for what to do if they came about.

Leaders who accept this tend to decide sooner and with less anxiety. They do not need every decision to succeed. They need each one to be well made, and they need to notice early when one is not working.

What is on offer instead

Certainty is not on offer. What is on offer is a clear view of what you know, what you do not, what it would cost to find out, and what you will do if you turn out to be wrong. With that view, you can choose. Without it, waiting will always look safer than it is.