03Perspectives

Comparing options when one is already favoured

Most decisions arrive with a favourite. Comparing the options fairly means testing the favourite hardest, not defending it.

Few decisions reach a board with every option on equal terms. Someone has usually found the site, met the buyer or drafted the plan. By the time the options are written down, one of them has a champion and the others have a list of objections.

That is not a failing. Favourites form because people have done work, and the work is often good. The difficulty is what happens next. Once an option has a champion, the comparison tends to become a defence. The favourite is examined for reasons it might work. The others are examined for reasons they will not. Each paper looks thorough on its own. Side by side, they are answering different questions.

Ask how the favourite was chosen

Before comparing anything, ask how the favourite became the favourite. Sometimes it won a fair contest earlier on. More often it arrived first, or came from the most senior person in the room, or is the option someone has already spent money on. None of those is a reason to reject it. Each is a reason to test it properly.

It helps to write down, in one sentence, why the favourite is favoured. If the sentence is “it is the one we have looked at most”, that describes effort, not merit.

Use the same tests for every option

The most practical step is to decide the tests before looking at the answers. What matters for this decision? Cost, time, risk, the effect on customers, the demand on the people who run the business, and how easily the choice could be reversed are common tests. Agree the list, and agree roughly how much each test matters, before anyone scores an option.

Then apply every test to every option, including the option of changing nothing. A table helps. Put the options across the top and the tests down the side, and in each cell write a short answer with its evidence. The table does not make the decision. It shows where the options differ, and where the only difference is how much has been written about them.

Two things usually come out of the table. First, the favourite’s advantages are real but narrower than they seemed. Second, the evidence is uneven. The favourite has been costed to the pound, and the alternatives have been costed on the back of an envelope. Where the evidence is uneven, say so in the table, and decide whether it is worth evening up before you choose.

Give each alternative a champion

An option with no advocate loses by default. One remedy is to ask someone to make the strongest honest case for each alternative. This should not be a straw man, or a contrarian arguing for sport. It should be someone who takes the option seriously and develops it as far as the favourite has been developed.

The person who championed the favourite may find this uncomfortable. It need not be a contest. The aim is not to defeat the favourite but to find out whether it still wins when the others are given a fair chance. If it does, the decision is stronger, and the board can say why it rejected the alternatives.

Take “do nothing” seriously

Changing nothing is almost always an option, and it is almost always treated as the thing to beat rather than as a real choice. It has costs: the opportunity passed up, and the problem left to grow. It also has merits that are easy to overlook. It keeps cash, it keeps other options open, and it avoids the distraction of a large project.

Write up “do nothing” as fully as any other option. If the case for action cannot beat it clearly, that is worth knowing before you commit.

Imagine that it has failed

One more test is worth the hour it takes. Assume the favoured option has been chosen and that, two years later, it has failed. Ask the people around the table to write down why. The exercise works because it gives permission to say things that would feel disloyal while the option is still a proposal. The reasons people write down are often the risks that nobody had listed.

Run the same exercise on the alternatives. Sometimes it shows that their risks are smaller than they first seemed.

Then choose

None of this is meant to stop you choosing the favourite. Often it remains the right answer, and now you know why. The purpose is to make sure the decision is a choice between options, and not the approval of one option that was settled in advance.

A board that has compared its options honestly can explain its decision to a lender, to its staff and to itself. It can say what it gave up and why. That explanation is worth having long after the decision is made, and most of all when circumstances change and the decision has to be looked at again.